After three years of watching (not straight, but once a week at least) Supernatural, Dude 1 and I…

After three years of watching (not straight, but once a week at least) Supernatural, Dude 1 and I have nearly caught up to real time which means we are waiting for the most recently aired season to come over to Netflix. Any other recommendations for multi-season shows we might like (we also watched Vampire Diaries during the same time frame)? It doesn’t have to be in the super natural genre, but we won’t complain if it is. Note: Dude 1 is a 17 year old boy who was 100% opposed to watching 90210 with me. 😬