Yes, anytime he has any type of bottom on he goes in them. I guess I’ll need to find our “fish” lol I’m not sure what would motivate him

I assume you've stressed to him that he can't go in his underwear.... We bought my son a fish for not using diapers. When I would put underwear on him, I'd say, "now we can't go potty in our underwear. You have a fish now so you have to go in the potty. Do not go in your underwear." The fish made a huge difference in potty training with my son.

If he's using the potty with no problem when he doesn't have a pull up on... I'd guess he's ready. Maybe a pull up is too much like a diaper for him??? We didn't use pull ups so I don't know... But he's doing it in underwear too, right?🤔 if I were you I think I'd stick with it for awhile longer, and just continue to leave him naked and then try underwear off and on...

@britt., we don’t mind at home lol he’s got it down until we put a pull up on. Do you think it’s just too early for him to understand not to go in the pull up? Or is he just lazy lol

Let him be naked! If you're home, why not?? Once he's got the potty thing down, then start working on underwear.