Reason for c section My first birth was vaginal but her heart rate kept dropping as I was pushing so…

No experience personally, but I don't necessarily think so. I nearly had an emergency c-section because Noah's heart rate kept dropping. I had to have an episiotomy to avoid major tearing and get him out quicker. I'd think it would be almost impossible to say if that would happen with the following pregnancy during labour.

With my first my daughter's heart rate kept dropping with each contraction & it turned out the cord was around her neck twice & she had to be delivered in theatre. I had 3rd degree tearing & an episiotomy. When it came to having my son he was a big baby (8.8pounds/4 kg) & it was recommended I have a c-section to avoid future incontinence from both areas. However I was given a choice - I did chose the c-section but my recovery from my first birth was long & very painful.

It is always 100% your choice what birth you have. I had tearing internally (required surgery after my son was born) & I always said I'd have a c-section & the Doctors said they wouldn't know if the same issue would happen again until I was pushing but there was also nothing leading them to believe it would happen (they don't know squat either way) & I booked in a planned c-section.

With my boy (first baby), his heart rate was dropping with contractions in early labour and I had an emergency c section.

Went on to have a vbac 18months later.

As pp said, it is always your choice. They won't take you into theatre if you don't sign the papers. Everything is your choice even though we often feel/get told, we have to do certain things.

I can't imagine they'd recommend a c-section for that reason alone. Each pregnancy and birth can be so different, they won't know if the same thing is gonna happen until you're in labour next time and even if it does, they don't always have to do a c-sec, it depends on lots of things.

I would think heart rate dropping is an individual baby thing and not a reason to consider a c section.

I had an emergency c-section because my sons heart rate drop to 30 bpm so they had to rush me off for one. But he was also very destrested. And I was extremely scared but am very very thankful that they had taken me in when they did.

I had a very similar first labour as yours & then went on to have a 2nd baby 15 months later with no complications what so ever during the birth.