I think it would be fun. They will anticipate the next day. But putting a note on the box when it comes is a good idea too. Then it’s just a surprise! Lol

That's a good idea ray! I was thinking of putting a note on the box once it arrives saying something like "I forgot this on my sleigh..." but that's a good idea too, like "the elves are still finishing up one more gift..." Lol. Idk, I'm just so bummed.

Maybe have santa leave them a note saying he’s got one more surprise on the way?

Oh no, I'm so sorry ur having a similar issue! It definitely sucks!

My youngest won't really care but it's the one thing my oldest daughter asked for. She's convinced Santa's bringing it for her ?. I'm truly hoping the excitement of everything else will distract her from it missing but with my luck she'll notice right away!

I’m with you. The only thing my step daughter asked for was a specific pair of shoes. I ordered then two weeks ago, paid extra shipping and they still won’t get to her on time. ?‍♀️. I sent a digital gift card to try and make up for it but it still sucks. Was the gift something your gifts were expecting?