Our problem at McDonald's when I was working there was that we would often only get a shipment of three different toys at any given time. We tried to circulate the toys, but somehow would always run out and have the same toy for two weeks until the next shipment came in.

Or we would have people come in looking for a specific number on the toys and buy them all out, and people would be angry they didn't get a different toy for the third time this week.

As long as it still wrapped, i dont see an issue. We have exchanged ours few times.

We have people ask us all the time where I work and unless we are busy and ask fur a specific toy when busy I don't mind. If we are busy I grab the one of each of the ones we gave upfront and tell them this us what we gave and let them choose. I do that when not busy and if not busy and they ask for specific toy if we don't have upfront I will go look in our stash in back.

You can ask if they say no they say no but more often than not they swap

The only reason we ever went to mcdonalds when we were little was for the teenie-beanies in the happy meals. If we got ones we already had then my mom would go up and ask to exchange them, I don't think they ever had an issue with it.

I see no reason not to ask. The worst thing that'll happen, is they could say no lol. Always worth asking.

My mom used to ask them to switch our toys all the time. I'd ask if I noticed

We've switched in quite a few toys before. I've never thought nothing of it

Not weird we've done it before. I've never had the employee be rude or anything

Why wouldn't you? Haha! I always have ?