I think they all run very big.

It depends in what cut you got, before I was pregnant, I wore a 14 in Rockstar and a 10 in sweetheart, their sizing on jeans varies greatly!

Run big. I wear a size 4 there. At most places I'm a 6. I can't even squeeze into a four at target.

They run big on me and they didn't really flatter my hips and butt.

I think all of their styles for differently on everyone. Personally, they aren't my favorite for a good fit but I think it's just all about body type. I am a 12/14 and pre pregnancy I was a 12, post the 14 fits best because of how my hips changed.

I agree with pp, I have never found pants there that fit me right so I think they're mostly ment for one body type

I get old navy jeans and they all fit a bit differently. I get sweetheart skinny but I get them long even though I'm only 5' 7". I have three pairs, all in different colours /washes , and they fit a bit differently too since the fabrics aren't the same. Divas in the same size were too small.

One word of warning though, if you get the super dark wash, be prepared to have the dye rub off a lot. I think there is a way to set the colour but mine that have been washed at least a dozen times still make my hands blue.

I have a huge butt, targets jeans just don't work for me. Old Navy actually runs a bit big and depending on the style it's a hit or miss.

To me they run small I wear 6 and a 8 in their jeans but other brands I wear a bigger size. I love their jeans though. Just brought another pair yesterday.

I wear the sweetheart jeans

I got a big ass, big thighs and big hips....jeans are so hit or miss. I went back to target and picked up 4 other styles from the ones I got yesterday and only 1 of them worked. They are either too tight, or the rise is too low. I don't like hip huggers. I want mom jeans ?

I ONLY like the rock stars, even those are eh.

To me their cuts are always tight in the waist and butt but big everywhere else.

I'm Hispanic though, so I have thinner legs and bigger hips/butt.

I find better jeans at American eagle (high waist jeggings) and ross to be honest!

I have both the sweetheart and rockstar and find they both fit a littleee small but pretty true to size

It depends on the style. "Diva" fit me true to size, but I'd say "Rockstar" runs 1-2 sizes small.

I got 2 sweetheart and 3 rockstar. I wanted skinny jeans and they didn't have anything but those in my size

It depends on wjat type of jeans you get. The diva, the sweet heart, the flirt, and some other type I can't remember are all cut different. The diva fits me true to size but the sweet heart I have to go up a size. Hope that was helpful.

I'm not pregnant lol just regular old jeans. I have a huge ass FWIW

They run big, and I'm a big girl. Pre-pregnancy I was a size 14, and I bought a size 14 maternity. They fit great! If I were to buy a size 14 in their regular jeans, I'd need a 16. So I guess you should just purchase your pre-pregnancy size. Hope that helps. And btw, their maternity jeans are soooo comfy!!!

I am also an 11/12 and I find the 12s are a bit too big. I ended up getting a pair of 10s and they're not bad. I actually just bought a couple pairs of maternity jeans from there on Friday and bought them in a 12. They're a bit loose in the legs and bum but hoping they fit better after a wash or two.

The rockstar skinnies have been great for me after pregnancies too. Enough stretch to avoid muffin top.

Just adding perspective on what I mean.

I am a true 6 in the waist not pregnant and my butt is 8 Or 10.

So my problem with jeans that are not from old navy is I have to buy the sizes 8-10 but they sag at my waist but that's the only sizes that fit my butt

I can actually old navy 6s and don't have to go up a size and risk baggy waist

Just read the comments and it totally makes sense that some would say it was too big in the butt if you don't have a big butt.

So yes. If you have a smaller backside they won't fit but they are a God send for those with my body type

They work perfect for me.

Old navy jeans are the best because I have a smaller waist but a huge bubble butt.

To me the diva jeans from old navy fit my waist but I can still fit my butt perfect too.

I have a problem of other jeans where I have to buy them to fit my butt but they sag because my waist is too small for them, But if I buy them for my waist my butt doesn't fit.

I love old navy diva jeans because I don't have that problem.

But if you don't have that body type they might not work.

Trial and error

They run big for me.

Last time I shopped there I had to order a size smaller. I have to go up at target too. But I think that's because I shop the juniors section.

They're big in the butt for me, but its the only store I know of that carries jeans with a long inseam. Anything else is ankle length for me

I think they run big

They run small imo