Mamas what would you do??

I currently have a job with great hours 6-2 m-f but the job work can be inconsistent and we sometimes get off early. I have a new job offer starting at 2pm-10pm m-f. My LO usually is most active after 2. So now i feel like i still spending the whole day with her but if i work at 2 i feel like i will miss alot. The position also pay $3 an hour more and in the same area.