For my baby shower I received a momaroo and a Fisher price cradle and swing. Thinking the momaroo was obviously better, I returned the swing to put money towards a stroller. Well my baby hardly ever likes being in the momaroo and she never naps in it. I took her to my friends house and put her in their cradle swing and she LOVED it. And she fell asleep after 15 minutes of just chilling. So we bought a used swing on offer up. She's already napped in there twice. But the guy we got it from said his baby hated the swing and loves the momaroo. Lol you can't win.