Which one do y'all think is best to do Natural birth or water birth?

Both are essentially the same thing one is just in the water. But I hear that doing a water birth the water helps a lot with the pain

I wanted a water birth... But the hospital I was at didn't allow that so I did a natural with my first instead... It's about what you think you'll be comfy with & have a backup

See I had a medication on my first child and I'm trying not to let them pork me in my back again because I have bad pain in my back so I really wanted to know would water birth really help with the pain.

I was able to stand in the shower At my hospital when I had my third baby up until i just couldn't stand through the contractions anymore then they had me lay down

See I'm thinking about the water birth but my bf/ baby daddy thinks that's nasty. So he don't wanna do it.

I mean he doesn't have to be in the water with you

Ohkay I might think about going the water birth

I wanted to try a water birth since this is my husband and i last baby and I told him I wanted to try a water birth and or a home birth and you would of thought I murdered someone with his reaction.