Also not sure if you used foundation but tinted moisturizer is my bff... easy, hydrates the skin, gives you some coverage and looks natural.

You have a beautiful eye color.. do a thinner eye liner, less is more :)

I agree about the brows! I’d just take a little brow pomade on an angled brush to extend the tails a bit.

With eyeliner I’d probably go a bit thinner with the line, but if what you’re wanting is that dramatic wing look, I’d go a bit softer on the bottom lash line or skip the liner there altogether. Going thick on both bottom and top can look a little harsh 😉

@olivbee it's hard for me to see without my glasses

Your brows actually look 100% better in the pic you posted without makeup! You don’t even need to fill them in. You were blessed with full dark brows.

Your hair looks good! The makeup isn’t horrible but I feel like the eyeliner & brows are actually taking away from your look. The liner is uneven & the brows are off. The one on the right (your left?) is too boxy and I can’t really tell what’s going on with the one on the left but it’s doesn’t look great. The lipstick is pretty though. I’d also suggest some blush or bronzer to warm up the face a little.

I can't see without my glasses lol

You look pretty bet you don't need make up but you could fix the eye liner and eye brows a lil... They look uneven but practice, I watch YouTube videos all the time to get that I'm looking for .. It helps me

On my eyebrows or eyeliner

I think your skin is very fair so instead of black I suggest brown makeup and hair instead of black. It doesn't look awful I just think it's too dark. You have nice eyes, you don't need all that makeup anyway.