Awesome thanks for the advice

Our redirect turned into a permanent solution. They are now stored in a large plastic bin out of reach. We never really re-watch movies anyway.

Great! That's What I have been doing but then I began second-guessing myself good to know I'm on the right track thank you

Just keep redirecting him/her to a toy of their own. They will get the jist of what your trying to say. Also tell them no that's mommy's .