My daughter is only 9 months old but I did a toothbrush and toothpaste, snacks, new straw cup, socks, earrings, a stuffed Peppa pig (she's obsessed with Peppa pig), a small 1st Christmas book and I think that is it. You could get your daughter snacks, new cup, maybe mini mms as a treat or a Hershey bar (my daughter has had both as a treat every once in a while), a movie she likes or stuffed animal. We also did a Christmas Eve box that has a pair of pjs, Peppa pigs Christmas movie, new straw cup and snacks and she will get to open it Christmas Eve night and we will put our pjs on and watch Peppa pig. She is a little small for it this year but I wanted to make it a tradition lol.